Violin Diaries – February 9, 2020

Second concert of the year finished and I think of a common question for many amateur and professional violinists alike: when to say yes or no to orchestral playing.

Is orchestral playing truly a match for your violin journey?

It seems to be a recurring question for many violinists I work with.

Some violinists see orchestral playing as prestigious and that it affects their identity as a violinist where they play and/or how much money they recieve. Or perhaps they have truly arrived when they are sitting on the stage performing with an orchestra.

Truth of the matter is, orchestral playing is for you if it benefits and nourishes your journey as a violinist. If all you take away is stress and your personal practice for improvement is depleted because you focus only on orchestral playing…perhaps it is something for you to deeply reconsider.

Recently, I played a program including Mozart’s Eine Kleine Nachtmusik. What I have found in my violin journey is musicians and conductors underestimate the difficulty of what they perceive as “simple” music. In my opinion, anything by Mozart should NEVER be underestimated.

Musicians have so many varying ideas of how Mozart has to be played that I honestly believe it has turned into a horrific complex.

In my current orchestra musicians, were scared to death of Bartok but not one word for Mozart – not a good combination when the young guest conductor also underestimates Mozart to the point it was completely under rehearsed and was more of an after thought.

As an orchestral player, one has to realize that we are thrown in specific situations that may not be ideal but one thing we do have control over, is our personal artistry.

Over the years after working with many adult violinists online who play in orchestras, I have to say some of them (who are limited on time) would benefit not playing in an orchestra at all and take that same time to devote to personally improving their craft.

But for some, it is easier to give that time to someone else.

Devoting time to your improving your artistry as a violinist is a form of self-love and personal growth and only you can decide how orchestral playing does or does not fit into that spectrum.

Perhaps it is time to ask yourself, why play in an orchestra…

Many people believe there is a prestige factor in playing in an orchestra.

And yes, while that is true don’t let it blind you from knowing whether it is for you or not.

Read below 5 steps to discover if your orchestral journey is benefitting you as a violinist or is a huge energy drain.

  • Take an unbiased (as possible) reality check of your present orchestral situation.

    Honestly weigh out the pluses and minuses. Make a list of what benefits do you recieve to devote your time and energy to a specific orchestra? Make an honest list of what depletes your violin journey from playing in a specific orchestra?

  • Ask yourself what is your dream orchestra job?

    Not with what orchestra but with what lifestyle situation.

    For example, is it to play only one concert a month, to have daily rehearsals, to walk to rehearsals or drive hours one way to get to that rehearsal.

    What are your priorities, quality or ease?

  • Do you feel you are a valuable asset to the group?

    Are you allowed to make the impact that you feel you have to offer the group or do you feel that it is best to stay quiet and watch the show unfold around you.

    Are you supportive of your fellow musicians? Are they supportive of you? or perhaps that isn’t of importance for you.

  • Emotional Evaluation - How do you feel?

    Do you feel lit up to play with your orchestra, do you love your concerts and rehearsals?

    Or

    Do you feel like a washrag that just cleaned four houses without getting rinsed.

  • Playing Evaluation - Are you a better violinist from the experience or not so much

    Do you feel you are learning from those around you or your intonation is being question by everyone else’s version of the pitch?

Obviously these five contemplative questions are only the starting point of balancing out your pluses and minuses to truly know if orchestral playing is for you. Most of the time you know deep down what is good for your journey or not but on the surface you may not allow yourself to truly know.

Ask yourself, “Is playing with {name your orchestra here} beneficial to my violin journey?” where do you feel the answer in your body? A happy heartfelt yes or a pit of the stomach heavy no….

You know 🙂

Now, I would love to hear from you. Have you had situations where you have chosen not to play in an orchestra to devote more time to your craft? Or perhaps you have found the perfect match of an orchestra for your violin journey.

Let us know 🙂

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *